The first video-
The first video talks about how the government and the military helped the Japanese-Americans evacuate the area. The US citizens thought the Japanese-Americans were threats, especially since Pearl Harbor was bombed just a few days ago. The military built these internment camps, where the Japanese-Americans were guarded and they lived there. Some of the events in the video did not sound very true to me. I do not think this video accurately portrays the Japanese-Americans during this time. A few reasons why I think this could include, first the narrator called the Japanese-Americans ‘aliens’. Aliens are not real and do not exist. The Japanese-Americans were real people born in America. Another reason could be the narrator made the internment camps sound like small apartment houses. We learn later the internment camps were not little apartments. The narrator made it sound like life went back to normal, after the Japanese-Americans evacuated. The next reason I think this isn’t accurate is that the narrator called the internment camps ‘assembly centers’. They are not assembly centers. That is where the Japanese-Americans live. The fourth reason is I don’t think the video portrayed the community’s social aspect nicely. The narrator made it sound like there were all these teachers, doctors, priests, and more, when really the camps were guarded, and the Japanese-Americans were in isolation. Lastly the narrator says the Japanese-Americans ‘gave up’ their homes and small businesses, when really they were forced to leave and many of them went homeless, once they returned home.
The second video-
It talks about the military and the government helping the Japanese-Americans evacuate as well. The person telling the story was saying how the Japanese-Americans immigrants were not allowed in the United States, because of the bombing of Pearl Harbor. Some of these events sounded mostly accurate. I think this video is accurate for a couple of reasons. One being the narrator had said ⅔ of them were American born citizens. They went to the internment camps, the US citizens who did not go to the camps, thought the Japanese-Americans were disloyal, which had caused them to be put in the camps, which is about 66% of the population in the western United States. The narrator had mentioned there were about 120,000 Americans, in all of the 10 camps. Another reason I think this is accurate is because of the barbed wire surrounding the camps. Barbed wire originated from the US in 1847. It also just seems like an American thing to do. The narrator, the storyteller, had said the Japanese-Americans were in isolation and had little privacy, whereas the other video made it sound like they had a tiny house. The story teller had also said the people were under harsh surveillance with little warmth in their living spaces. This was because the camps were in deserted areas of the western United States. The next reason is the narrator had said there was a big community, which made life more normal. I think that is pretty accurate except I still don’t know how they got all those teachers, doctors, and priests to come in.
Although both videos told the same story, I think the second video told the more accurate version. More of the events that happened sound more true. Because the narrator of the first video had called the Japanese-Americans ‘aliens’, I believe that is not accurate and false. The Japanese-Americans were born in America. They are actual American citizens. Asian immigrants were known as ‘economic threats’. But they aren’t threats, they didn’t do anything to hurt the US.